Page 1 of 1

rating system

Posted: Fri Oct 04, 2024 5:22 am
by buratino
start of the season ... general queston - howto rate players? leadership table is a piece of sh111t

the first point - boehmi's formula is good enough in the end of the season but not good enough in the first two weeks of the season . agree ?

the second point - relation "rate_of_games | number_of_games" where rate of games is 15 * #1 + 9 * #2 + 6 * #3 + ... is OBJECTIVE true metric . not "divide" - just "relation" . agree ?

if the answer is '"yes" to the both questions than i propose the new formula for leadership board metric :
" rate_of_games * number_of_games / 100"

( 100 is chosen for sake of resemblance to boehmi's coefficient and is discussable )

objections ?

Re: rating system

Posted: Sun Oct 06, 2024 3:39 pm
by Sterling800
:ugeek: It's been almost a week. There's 350 rated players. I think the site is dying. They don't update it. They don't try to do better. Nobody's engaging
The players are not fun to play with, it's over.

Re: rating system

Posted: Mon Oct 07, 2024 2:50 pm
by boehmi
buratino wrote: Fri Oct 04, 2024 5:22 am start of the season ... general queston - howto rate players? leadership table is a piece of sh111t

the first point - boehmi's formula is good enough in the end of the season but not good enough in the first two weeks of the season . agree ?

the second point - relation "rate_of_games | number_of_games" where rate of games is 15 * #1 + 9 * #2 + 6 * #3 + ... is OBJECTIVE true metric . not "divide" - just "relation" . agree ?

if the answer is '"yes" to the both questions than i propose the new formula for leadership board metric :
" rate_of_games * number_of_games / 100"

( 100 is chosen for sake of resemblance to boehmi's coefficient and is discussable )

objections ?
On the 4th the ranking was already sufficiently good. Only player with an average of > 5 were in the top 10 AFAIR.

Look at the graph for the coefficient (1 - 10000 / (10000 + games^3))

https://www.desmos.com/calculator/qhsmq0gz4o

and you might understand what it does.

Re: rating system

Posted: Tue Oct 08, 2024 9:31 am
by buratino
guten tag boehmi

i saw this curve last time we discuss the matter - several years ago :-)

but i still suppose that relation " rate|#games " is the best metric

and i have just realized (yes , i am pockemon , sorry) that users can choose sorting in the leadership table - so for me personally - there is " no problema " at all now

brgds